Forumics logo Forumics
Issue 01

Back to issue

All Claude Code known issues

CLAIM C128 Supported 2026-11-15

GitHub issue #65620 in anthropics/claude-code, opened 2026-06-05 by ingo-eichhorst, records a report that since about v2.1.162 (still present on 2.1.165), assistant text blocks are silently dropped from the session transcript whenever the model emits another interleaved thinking block after the text in the same turn, with onset around 2026-06-04; the prose is rendered on screen but appears nowhere in the file, and the two persisted thinking blocks carry distinct signatures; in two sessions analyzed line by line, every turn shaped thinking-text-tool_use kept its text while every turn shaped thinking-thinking-tool_use corresponded to an on-screen prose message absent from the JSONL, and zero persisted text-to-thinking shapes appeared across both sessions; v2.1.158 transcripts from the same machine and model persist every text block. System cited: claude 2.1.165 (also observed on 2.1.162), macOS, model claude-opus-4-8 (1M context).

Verbatim Excerpts from Cited Records
“The prose is rendered on screen but appears **nowhere in the file** — not as text, not inside thinking, not in any other line type.”
— ingo-eichhorst · anthropics/claude-code (issue 65620 opening body, Summary section) · 2026-06-05T09:34:10Z ·GitHub Issue ↗
“The two persisted thinking blocks carry distinct signatures (both genuine); only the sandwiched text vanishes.”
— ingo-eichhorst · anthropics/claude-code (issue 65620 opening body, Summary section) · 2026-06-05T09:34:10Z ·GitHub Issue ↗
“Session A (2.1.165, 35 API turns): every turn shaped `thinking+text+tool_use…` kept its text (10/10); every turn shaped `thinking+thinking+tool_use…` (15) corresponds to an on-screen prose message that is absent from the JSONL — verified by grepping the raw file for exact on-screen sentences (0 hits).”
— ingo-eichhorst · anthropics/claude-code (issue 65620 opening body, Evidence section) · 2026-06-05T09:34:10Z ·GitHub Issue ↗
“Every transcript consumer (analytics, observability tools, transcript viewers, custom tooling reading `~/.claude/projects`) sees roughly half the assistant prose missing in tool-heavy Opus sessions”
— ingo-eichhorst · anthropics/claude-code (issue 65620 opening body, Impact section) · 2026-06-05T09:34:10Z ·GitHub Issue ↗
Counter-record: Issue open as of the fetch; all 33 comments read. Oxygen56 (2026-06-05) analyzed the streaming-event pipeline and how text blocks get dropped at persistence. AnnaThyme (2026-06-06) confirmed on Windows and ran a version census (2.1.145-158: 0/347 messages affected, 2.1.162: 8/15, 2.1.165: 22/52), arguing the text was never emitted as a text block. topp (2026-06-06) added date-onset data (same client 2.1.161, same model: 0/426 affected on June 3, 22/124 on June 4) and a same-day bisect localizing the change to v2.1.160 to v2.1.161, then multi-day version-by-date data arguing the onset is server-gated. ingo-eichhorst (2026-06-06) consolidated the thread and withdrew the version-regression framing in his own title as probably wrong. topp and oskar-gm (2026-06-06) flagged the tension that a same-day A/B changing only the client version pointed the other way. Nharu (2026-06-07) identified the root cause as the narration_summaries beta, the second thinking block being a narration block verifiable by decoding its signature, and later confirmed the beta header itself is not the trigger. spiky02plateau (2026-06-10) reported escalation to the GA Fable 5 stack and that pinning to 2.1.160 avoided it. kiyor (2026-06-10) added an independent setup and linked #67164. ingo-eichhorst (2026-06-12) reported the loss had cleared on one account, evidence the gate is account-bucketed. oskar-gm (2026-06-13) and topp (2026-06-14) corroborated the rollback from two further accounts, topp noting this is off, not fixed. topp (2026-07-03) reported the bucket flipped back on, on Fable 5 at v2.1.199. gearghost-tyler (2026-07-08) confirmed the bucket on in the VS Code native extension and that alwaysThinkingEnabled false and a MAX_THINKING_TOKENS cap do not mitigate. spiky02plateau (2026-07-17) found the client stopped shipping the feature after 2.1.201 while the server still sends it. geoh (2026-07-29, 2026-08-03, 2026-08-05) published a workaround hook and refined the detection. ralucaoda (2026-08-02) and Ornolfr (2026-09-02) confirmed it still present in 2.1.219 and 2.1.258 on Fable 5 and 5.1. glen-84 (2026-08-24) noted the duplicate cluster. luketraas (2026-11-14) confirmed it still present on 2026-11-14, CLI 2.1.325, on claude-opus-5-5 and claude-fable-5-2, at roughly 1 in 3 tool-calling turns stored as narration since June, and not tied to the thinking-display setting. No retraction of the report appears in the thread. Related published claims C099 (#65051), C017 (#74260) and C088 (#74558) are distinct issue reports in the same text-loss cluster, by different authors with different measurements; this claim documents only #65620, whose original report is that prose is rendered on screen but absent from the transcript file. Falsification probe: If GitHub issue #65620 is deleted without archive, if the author edits the opening body so the quoted sentences no longer match verbatim, or if the author posts a retraction of the report, this claim drops to Withdrawn. Audit verification: Verified 100% continuous verbatim substring against official GitHub REST API by scripts/verify_claim_verbatim.py.