GitHub issue #54685 in openai/codex, opened 2026-10-16 by n0rpan123, records a report that a naturally required cross-task execution review denied a bounded QA installation because the trusted user context contained only an abbreviated Approved with omitted context, even though the exact approval request contained the complete original proposal and reply, original message identifiers and hashes, and a read-only original-record locator. The final decision was risk level high, user authorization unknown, outcome deny, and the report asks maintainers whether this is a trusted-context retention or attribution defect, a reviewer evidence-verification failure, or a currently unsupported cross-task authorization path.
Verbatim Excerpts from Cited Records
“A naturally required cross-task execution review denied a bounded QA installation because trusted user context contained only an abbreviated “Approved” with omitted context, even though the exact approval request contained the complete original proposal/reply, original message identifiers and hashes, and a read-only original-record locator.”
·
openai/codex (issue 54685 opening body, What issue are you seeing section)
·
2026-10-16T19:26:10Z
·GitHub Issue ↗
“The question for maintainers is whether this is a trusted-context retention/attribution defect, a reviewer evidence-verification failure, or a currently unsupported cross-task authorization path.”
·
openai/codex (issue 54685 opening body, What issue are you seeing section)
·
2026-10-16T19:26:10Z
·GitHub Issue ↗
“The final decision was `risk_level: high`, `user_authorization: unknown`, `outcome: deny`. Its rationale said the visible trusted user message only said “Approved” after omitted context and did not establish approval for the exact package.”
·
openai/codex (issue 54685 opening body, Sanitized supporting evidence section)
·
2026-10-16T19:26:10Z
·GitHub Issue ↗
“The reviewer should evaluate the actual action against authentic original human approval using a documented, supported provenance path. If the original context is retrievable, it should not dismiss the case as merely an unexplained “Approved” without evaluating that context.”
·
openai/codex (issue 54685 opening body, What is the expected behavior section)
·
2026-10-16T19:26:10Z
·GitHub Issue ↗
Counter-record: Issue remains open. API returned 22 comments; all 22 were read. github-actions[bot] (2026-10-16) flagged #54456, #54524 and #54644 as potential duplicates; the author reviewed them on 2026-10-17, noted substantial symptom overlap, and asked for consolidation into the appropriate existing tracker if already covered. The author then added further naturally occurring cases on 2026-10-17 through 2026-11-08 with the same authorization-recognition pattern, and d8v1d7-sys (2026-10-20) added a macOS desktop observation. No maintainer response appears in the thread. No retraction or correction appears in the thread. The claim documents only the original report and its follow-up observations, not a verified current state.
Falsification probe: If issue 54685 is deleted without archive, if the author edits the opening body so the quoted sentences no longer match verbatim, or if the author posts a retraction of the report, this claim drops to Withdrawn.
Audit verification: Verified 100% continuous verbatim substring against official GitHub REST API by
scripts/verify_claim_verbatim.py.